Meet Captain Jim Holtzman

For Captain Jim Fishel, fishing Lake Erie is more than just a career—it’s a lifelong passion. His journey began over three decades ago, when he started sharing his love for chasing Walleye with family and friends. Over the years, that passion grew into a guiding career built on knowledge, patience, and dedication to helping others discover the same joy he found on the water. Guests often remark that Jim’s enthusiasm is contagious, and his ability to make every outing enjoyable is what keeps anglers coming back year after year.

Captain Jim’s expertise doesn’t just come from time on the water—it comes from a lifetime of living and breathing Lake Erie’s unique fishery. With over 60 years of experience on the Great Lakes, he has witnessed the changes in fish populations, water conditions, and seasonal patterns. His stories of the legendary Blue Pike and insights into the Walleye migration reflect a deep understanding of the ecosystem that only decades of firsthand knowledge can provide. For visitors, that means more than just a fishing trip—it’s a chance to learn from a true Lake Erie historian and angler.

Since 1991, Captain Fishel has partnered with fellow guide Captain Jim Holtzman, combining their knowledge to create one of the most experienced teams on Lake Erie. Together, they bring over 100 years of fishing expertise to every charter, ensuring guests benefit from their shared skills, proven techniques, and dedication to making each outing both educational and enjoyable. Whether teaching the right bait to use, showing how to target feeding fish, or sharing tips from years of success, Captain Jim makes sure every guest feels like part of the crew.

About the Boat – Makin’ Memories

Fishing with Makin’ Memories Fishing Charters means stepping aboard a 30’ Cherokee offshore sportfishing boat designed for both comfort and performance. With a wide 12’ beam and spacious deck, the vessel easily accommodates six guests and crew without feeling crowded. Outfitted with advanced navigation systems and top-of-the-line fishing equipment, the boat is built for both safety and success. Every detail is designed so guests can focus on fishing while enjoying a smooth, secure ride across Lake Erie. Whether chasing trophy Walleye, jumbo Yellow Perch, or Steelhead Trout, the Makin’ Memories ensures your time on the water is as enjoyable as it is productive.