Makin' Memories Fishing Charters Customer Reviews

Name: Makin' Memories Fishing Charters
Brand: Makin' Memories Fishing Charters
Rating: 5 (7 reviews)

100% would recommend

5/5

From 7
verified reviews

Book Your Next Trip With Us

All Reviews

Pasquale Piscitelle

August 30, 2025

Trip - on August 30, 2025

I HAD BOOKED A CHARTER WITH ANOTHER CAPTAIN BUT HE REPLIED HIS MOTOR WAS DOWN . SO I BOOKED WITH JORDANNY AND HIS BROTHER AND BOY WERE WE GLAD. THEY WORKED LIKE A FINE OILED MACHINE . WE CAUGHT A 25-30 POUND WAHOO AND ABOUT 9 TUNA FROM SMALL TO AROUND 3-4 POUNDS. SO IF YALL ARE LOOKING FOR A EXCELLENT CHARTER WITH A RELIABLE CREW AND FRIENDLY PEOPLE THIS IS IT. THANX TO JORDANNY AND HIS BROTHER ARCHIE . CHEERS AMIGOS

Was this helpful ?

Adam Wright

February 19, 2024

Trip - on February 19, 2024

We had the best time with Captain Jim and his first mate. We caught a ton of fish and always felt safe.

Was this helpful ?

Jerry Mullins (Jerryschmo)

February 17, 2024

Trip - on February 17, 2024

This charter boats name exemplifies it all! Hands down the best charter boat and captain in Northeast Ohio. You are all but guaranteed to have a good time and likely catch your limits of Walleye! I have been on charters with him for 35 years and never am dissapointed.

Was this helpful ?

Bob Pardee

February 17, 2024

Trip - on February 17, 2024

If you want to be kept involved in a great fishing experience, then this is the trip for you. Mariah and Jimmy will keep you completely engaged in the best experience that I have ever had with any charter.

Was this helpful ?

Lisa Distel

February 17, 2024

Trip - on February 17, 2024

Fantastic time with a fantastic crew! Capt. Jimmy always finds his fish! Spacious boat and up to date gear. Will definitely book again!!

Was this helpful ?

John Hagstrom

February 17, 2024

Trip - on February 17, 2024

Take my work crew every summer with captain Jim. It is a highlight of the year for us. Very professional crew, always get our limit, large comfortable boat. I highly recommend Makin Memories.

Was this helpful ?

Mike Miller

February 17, 2024

Trip - on February 17, 2024

Hands down one of the best fishing trips you can take! We’ve been out with captain Jim multiple times and caught out limit every time

Was this helpful ?

Guided by Experience, Driven by Passion

What Guests Are Saying About Makin' Memories Fishing Charters in Lake Erie

At Makin' Memories Fishing Charters, customer reviews highlight the quality of our Lake Erie fishing trips and the expertise of Captain Jim and crew. Guests often share how much fun they had catching Walleye, Yellow Perch, and Steelhead, with many returning year after year for another charter. From families booking their first fishing experience to seasoned anglers chasing trophy catches, testimonials consistently point to a hands-on, well-guided trip that leaves lasting memories on the water. These Lake Erie fishing charter reviews also show the trust and loyalty built with repeat customers who value both the catches and the overall experience.

Trusted by Anglers Across Lake Erie

Our customer testimonials emphasize not just the fish but the professionalism, knowledge, and friendly support that make each outing special. Many reviews mention the excitement of filling coolers with Perch, reeling in hard-fighting Walleye, and learning new fishing techniques that improve skills. This feedback reassures future guests that our guided trips deliver on both fun and results. See what others are saying and book your Lake Erie fishing adventure with Makin' Memories Fishing Charters today!